Rank: Newbie
Groups: Registered
Joined: 12/14/2019(UTC) Posts: 9  Location: Pennsylvania
|
Originally Posted by: BOPDentist  allday721, I could not help but chime in here. When I had the PCS move done through the DOJ (which may be similar to the DOD), at first I had the same reservations and fears about tax burdens and my tax brackets, etc.... However, when it was all said and done, taxes filed, I'll tell you that I was pleasantly surprised; that it worked out well!
My biggest advice to you here: " if you a simple PCS move (see below) then don't over think the whole process & calculations too much".
So let me give you my example here....I PCS'ed from mid-west across to a state 950 miles east. And the entire cost of PCS is all taxable income as you know. If my relocation costs were 20,000. The DOJ reloc. specialist calculates roughly the taxes owed on that, say 8,000. So now my total amount to place into 1040 taxes is 28,000 (all taxable income). However, what I was pleasantly surprised to see was that relocation W2 already had the withholdings in it (this is the figure that you add along with your regular W2 for federal/state income taxes withheld; kind of like an offset), meaning I was not going to write a check for additional tax incurred due to that 28,000 (additional to taxable income). Yes, there can be a scenario where you may owe a small amount, small though, because they normally use a 2% withholding rate for state taxes, and some states have much higher state income tax rate. In my case I was moving to a state with a much higher state tax rate than 2% and I knew that well in advance. To counter it, I was already making higher state tax withholdings for the biweekly pay periods (via the state W4 form). Then the following year, that reloc. specialist will contact you again to "settle the RITA"; again a new, but much smaller taxable income will be generated, but like before, the withholdings will already be included! So you add the RITA amount to the taxable income, and the withholding from it to the taxes withheld section, and it all evens out.
In my case, and I imagine in most cases, people come out "on top" with a full PCS move.
I am aware that with some PCS moves, some people will have home sales (via the home sale program), or temporary lodgings, even have HHGs temporarily stored for a certain period of time. In such a case the entire PCS move may be generate a huge taxable income, but then it will also generate a much larger withholding amount to offset it! But I can imagine that such a large taxable amount being added in can push someone to the next tax bracket.
My above experience was for a typical PCS move that did not involve a home sale, temp lodgings, or HHG storage. It was a quick and easy move. If I did have a home, I had the option to sell it myself, and then the selling expenses could be refunded to me, up to a certain amount, as a part of the PCS move (which would increase the PCS cost, but also the withholding amount offset).
Hope it helps.
Originally Posted by: BOPDentist  …..and I forgot to add, that at least in my case, for the second year when the RITA was settled, that full amount was a direct deposit to the bank. So it is money in your bank, and not simply a figure that is added to 1040 taxable income without one even "seeing" that money in the bank. And the RITA W2 will also include the withholding in it.
Be aware that in all these calculations, the PCS cost is increased by amount of withholding to generate a tax burden. Meaning, if one had an actual PCS cost (movers, storage, etc) of #30,000 and such an income could generate like $10,000 in taxes, then the total PCS cost is $40,000 (not 30,000) in that first year of filing. The W2 would show income of $40,000, and a withholding of $10,000. In the second year, you will get back some/all of the money that arose due to the tax burden from the first year (using 40,000 as taxable income rather than 30,000). It does not mean you get 10,000 back, but you get the tax difference back from using 40,000 as taxable inc, versus 30,000 by means of tax brackets (marg tax rate) that applies. The amount you get back in bank the second year along with the new tax burden that it would incur, now serves as taxable income for the next year. When you file taxes that 2nd year thereafter, the whole process comes to an end.
It may seem complicated, but as I said before it has a way of "working out in favor of the employee" generally.
Anyone else can chime in if they think my explanation was off/wrong or of their experience was different. Again my experiences are based on a PCS move with the DOJ. BOP did you use WTA at all? My situation is the opposite as I am PCSing from the east coast to a location about 850miles away in the south where the state income tax is less than what I pay now. Did you have to pay anything out of pocket before the RITA was deposited the next year? Did you add any extra withholding in your checks or was the relocation automatically taken out? I am probably going to have as much withheld as I can afford for the next couple of months until the move just to be safe then worst case I'll get it back in a refund check.
|